Monday, February 29, 2016

Sex Trafficking of Minors: Know the Process, Look for the Signs

Under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act and its reauthorizations, in the U.S. no youth should be considered a “child prostitute”—minors (children under the age of 18) induced into commercial sex acts are, by definition, victims of human trafficking. Many of these victims are not kidnapped or confined, but lead “double lives,” going to school, living at home, and having apparently “normal” social lives, while concurrently being sold for sex by a trafficker-pimp through a process of manipulation that involves elements of psychological coercion, romancing, blackmail, and even physical violence. They might be sold for sex on weekends or afterschool, and the trafficker might be extra cautious about raising the suspicions of parents, guardians, and teachers. In some instances, the trafficker may even be a peer-aged boy/girlfriend.   

©istockphoto.com/tzahiV
In this article, we will briefly look at the process by which small-scale traffickers (the majority type of sex trafficker in the U.S.) lure, manipulate, and finally trap their minor victims in their exploitation schemes. Indicators, or “red flags,” can give hints to parents, friends, teachers, and school administrators about the process that a minor under their care might be undergoing. That a minor exhibits one, or even several of the following indicators, does not prove that he/she is a victim of trafficking, but it may warrant a greater vigilance and inquiry by those responsible for the safety and welfare of the minor. It also goes without saying that this list of indicators is not exhaustive. The process by which a minor falls into a sex trafficking scheme can be summarized in the following typical stages:

1)     “Grooming,” or “Seasoning” the Minor:  Considering that traffickers always choose the path ofleast resistance, not every minor is equally at risk. Traffickers will look for vulnerable children of all social/ethnic backgrounds that exhibit specific psychological characteristics that make them more prone to manipulation. In this stage, the trafficker will look for an “open door” by which to start the process of manipulation.  
      
They will look for children who:
  • Show signs of social exclusion/marginalization from family, friends, or peer romantic relationships, and express intentions online of running away.
  • Have a history of sexual or physical abuse.
  •  They meet either online or in-person, where they evaluate the self-esteem of the minor through psychologically astute questioning, analyzing the minor´s body language, eye contact, and even tone of voice. A common tactic is to compliment a potential victim. If the youth simply thanks the predator while looking at him/her straight in the eyes, then the the minor shows signs of self-valuation, and thus may not be an “easy target.” If, on the other hand, the minor looks down at the ground and either says nothing or rejects the compliment, the predator might infer a self-esteem problem, and may pursue him/her.
  • Escape from home and need basic needs met; the minor risks falling into a trafficking situation via “survival sex” after overstaying his/her welcome at the homes where he/she has been “couch surfing.”
At this point parents/guardians might start to notice the child acting differently:
©iStockphoto.com/MrPants
  • New “friends” emerge who are significantly older and outside the common peer social sphere; random new Facebook “friend requests.”
  • Minor becomes suddenly uninterested in activities/hobbies he/she liked.
  • Minor becomes dejected (more than might be usual), withdrawn, and seeks to be alone and on the phone a lot while talking to just a friend—the trafficker.
2)     Isolating the Minor: In this stage, the trafficker has already made inroads into the minor’s confidence. The trafficker will be “investing” in the minor by buying him/her gifts, taking him/her to adult parties, etc. Traffickers look for youths with histories of problems/abuse/neglect. If the trafficker “finds a problem” to latch on to, he/she will psychologically exacerbate that problem, magnify it, and manipulate the child into thinking that he/she is the “solution” to the problem, thereby marginalizing the child from family, friends, and social support structures. Some indicators are:
  • Youth carries unexplained cash and expensive gifts: This may have begun in the previous stage, but is usually intensified in this stage.
  • The lure of transgression: Increased alcohol use/abuse and use of drugs: The trafficker is pushing the minor into either dependency or a sense that with him/her the minor has more freedom (a false freedom dependent on the trafficker).
  •  Unusual rise in interest in/preoccupation with pornography.
  • The youth seems to “check-in” by phone or device to a “friend” constantly.
3)     The Minor Falls into the Trafficking Situation: At a certain point, either after thoroughly romancing the youth, or spending much time/money/gifts on him/her, the trafficker will “ask for a favor” which will be the first commercial sex act the minor does for the trafficker. Having been isolated from his/her former circles, and estranged from his/her parents, the minor will comply, sometimes with an interest in the money the trafficker/pimp promises. The trafficker may have a circle of youths who he/she is trafficking, and this circle will largely replace the minor´s previous social relations. Look for the following:
  • Carries lots of cash: Trafficker may indeed “pay” the minor, sometimes even hundreds of dollars per week (him/herself making SIGNIFICANTLY more).
  • Minor´s “other life” may start to encroach upon school and family time, as “dates” are scheduled by the trafficker at increasingly erratic times.
  • Unusual hours are kept; minor has problems sleeping/has nightmares.
  • Minor may start dressing in an especially hyper-sexualized style.  
  • Minor may be bruised: A trafficker will always prefer psychological manipulation and isolation to outright violence, but he/she may still resort to beatings/slapping.  
  •  Minor may be “branded” with tattoos: Less common if the trafficker wants to keep the minor leading a “double life,” but tattoos do not have to be names, they can be symbols shared by all the minors in that trafficker/pimp’s circle.
  • Minor may always “be able” to physically leave the trafficking situation: The “chains” are usually invisible, and often involve the “love” that the youth may have for the trafficker, threats to the minor’s family, money the trafficker/pimp shares, etc.

If you suspect a trafficking situation, call the National Human Trafficking Resource Center hotline: 1-888-373-7888, or text Help at 233733 (BeFree). 


This month's guest blogger: Christopher Ljundquist, National Outreach and Education Coordinator, U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops/Migration and Refugee Services (USCCB/MRS)

14 comments:

  1. Please share any additional tips/advice here! Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great advice- Local task forces and offices are available to further investigate the issue with you. We can call people with CPS directly with the factual information to prove the trafficking. :)

      National Human Trafficking Hotline 888-373-8888

      -Lisa, Catholic Charities Louisville

      Delete
  2. Approximately how many minors in the US are victims of human trafficking and in particular trafficked sexually in the US?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I did answered this same question during the webinar, but will answer again because it could help put a numerical perspective on the phenomenon: The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children estimates that the number is probably from 100,000 to 300,000, and the 100,000 figure is used by many advocates. That being said, the sad reality is that no one really knows, and there is no way of knowing, how many children are exploited in sex trafficking schemes in the United States.

      Delete
  3. Any advice in reporting sex trafficking once a minor is 17 closer to legal age?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This question, also very good, was asked during the recorded webinar. Under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act, a 17-year old is still a minor, and that case must be reported as just that, a minor being exploited in a sex trafficking scheme. Furthermore, given that the average "age of entry" is 12-14 (not an uncontested assertion), it is likely that the 17-year old may have been exploited for some years now, and may not find the ability to free him/herself until help comes.

      Delete
  4. Is it appropriate just to use hot line and give what you know without your name?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can certainly call the hotline and not disclose your name.

      Delete
  5. What are the stats on rescue and intervention to remove children from these situations once they have been trafficked over a period of time?

    ReplyDelete
  6. What should you do when agencies like CPS do not accept the report?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is a great question, and one that sometimes may be all too common. If you are receiving no help from relevant authorities, call the local human trafficking task force, whose members will help you determine what to do. The task forces are comprised of various different anti-trafficking agencies, including law enforcement and NGOs, and some organization in the task force will help. Many times victims of human trafficking are identified by NGOs and service providers and only afterwards is law enforcement involved.

      Delete
  7. What advice do you have for us about a caregiver that isolates a minor due to strict household rules?

    ReplyDelete
  8. What signs of human trafficking or risk of human trafficking should we watch out for in particular with refugee youths? Is there anything unique or especially pronounced that differs from US citizens and LPR? Have you noticed any trends among the new immigrants, refugees kids living in the US?

    ReplyDelete